Culture

How Do We Rightly Relate Liberty and Responsibility?

Post Icon
Editor's Note

Equipping articles aim to equip ministry leaders to advance the way of Christ in all of culture by 1) clarifying a particular cultural issue, 2) identifying the challenge it presents to Christians and the Church, and 3) offering a way forward for Christians and ministry leaders. These are typically short-form and not comprehensive in nature.

This article is part of our theme, The Way of Christ in Politics.

With responsibility comes liberty. Though people more often hear the opposite maxim, “With liberty comes responsibility,” we must reintroduce ourselves to the upstream influence that produces a flourishing society. The latter maxim focuses upon the misuse of liberty. The former points toward its purpose. As with the employee charged with a task that necessarily requires authorization to complete it, fundamental responsibilities—both personal and social—likewise demand the same authorization. For citizens, that involves exercising liberty.

Human flourishing occurs where creation order and enduring moral truth are reflected.

The liberty to fulfill fundamental responsibilities is necessary. When an individual has a legitimate responsibility without the freedom to pursue it, he faces an environment of frustration and cost. Public school teachers who’ve faced the threat of contract termination for refusing to use preferred pronouns stand as examples of this jeopardy. To speak the truth, they must ‘rebel’ against district policy.

That conundrum should not be created by civil or workplace authorities. Yes, one must responsibly exercise liberty; but more importantly, one must live up to fundamental responsibilities which require liberty, the God-ordained, inalienable rights, kind of liberty. So, what upstream influence determines fundamental responsibilities that, when pursued, produce a flourishing society?

Creation order and enduring moral truth define our responsibilities and animate the purpose of liberty. Though it is broadly rejected in our day, we should respect this upstream influence for its relationship to human flourishing. Rejecting it fosters reckless and irresponsible freedom (think libertinism), or intrusive violations of inalienable rights (think statism), and subsequently leads to societal decay. And unsurprisingly, that decay surrounds us.

If we start with the thesis, “To be human is to be free,” we lack a preceding, guiding principle that informs freedom. If, however, we start with “To be human is to be responsible before God,” something even greater than liberty itself directs freedom’s purpose.

We should desire ordered liberty over disordered liberty. The dangerous waters of unfettered freedom surround us. God created humanity for something far better than a life without restraint. Yet our culture assumes otherwise. Absent God’s guiding purpose, pride parade participants walk the route unclothed. Young children are exposed to gratuitously sexualized drag queens.

Throuples celebrate their progressive romantic relationships. The human cost of unfettered liberty like this shows up in therapist lobbies, emergency rooms, classrooms, and yes, even state budgets. Moral bankruptcy complicates our society in every sector of life. If that’s not enough, our libertine culture declares that those who pursue ordered liberty are threats.

Disordered liberty targets anyone who rejects its practice. Governing authorities, equally committed to the rejection of creation order and enduring moral truth, pass laws and regulations that require affirmation of their unfettered constituency. Additionally, they incentivize the private sector to follow suit. Whether one bakes cakes, creates satire, provides counseling services, plays sports, or simply raises kids in the Christian faith, capitulation is the order of the day—or else face statist imposed penalties. What’s to be done?

First, reinvigorate appreciation for creation order and enduring moral truth. This involves parents, pastors, educators, and legislators. Our culture will not regain an understanding of ordered liberty, let alone an appreciation for it, unless we address it within our own spheres of influence. This may require additional effort to educate ourselves on matters related to ordered liberty.

So be it. Nothing of consequence is casually secured. We must explain key concepts, provide examples, and discern distinctions. What is creation order? How does it relate to the “goods” of natural law? How do we describe enduring moral truth? Why must we define the ‘common good’ by relying on objective moral truth? We can’t commend what we don’t know.

Second, remind governing authorities that they, too, must respect ordered liberty of its citizenry. Neither the government nor its proxies have legitimate authority to intervene between individuals and their responsibility to submit to the creation order and enduring moral truth. When people order their lives in this fashion, they enjoy the blessings of the “goods” identified within natural law. People ought to enjoy the freedom to pursue such a life.

Government didn’t establish creation order or truth. Nor should the government dissuade its citizens from honoring them. It is true that the government plays a role in establishing laws that, in turn, inform ordered liberty. But only those laws that are complementary to creation order and enduring moral truth are appropriate. Those that stand in opposition create a context where citizens must ‘rebel’ to rightly pursue fundamental responsibilities. The government doesn’t stand over conscience in such cases. God does, the One to whom individuals owe ultimate obedience.

Human flourishing occurs where creation order and enduring moral truth are reflected. For these to be reflected, we must be free to pursue them. Without that liberty and its animating purpose, our society will continue to suffer. Let’s make our way upstream and champion today what our founders championed in their day: ordered liberty.

Never miss an episode, article, or event.

Sign up for the CFC Newsletter now!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

adblock image

MDiv Christian Ethics

The Christian Ethics track provides specialized academic training that prepares men and women to impact the culture for Christ through prophetic moral witness and service in a variety of settings.

Photo retrieved from Unsplash.

 

  • Culture
  • politics
Doug Richey

Doug Richey

Doug Richey (D.Min, Th.M., M.Div., M.A. - Biblical Languages, Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary) has served nearly thirty years as an SBC pastor, and also served three terms in the MO House of Representatives. He currently serves with Alliance Defending Freedom, on their public policy team, and is also a Senior Fellow with Do No Harm.

Never miss an episode, article, or study.

Sign up for the Christ and Culture newsletter now!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.